Saturday, July 6, 2013

Rugs: Tribal & Village, City and Workshop

Oriental Rugs are too broad a category with far too many twists and turns to take as a whole and attempt to learn. So to shortcut the process and make it manageable we use broad over simplifications to make it easier. One standard one today is based loosely on the work of Dr. Jon Thompson. We  take all rugs and break them into three types. Tribal and Village, City rugs, and Workshop Rugs. It is not perfect but it does give us a broad workable framework.

Tribal and Village Rugs



These are made by women without outside supervision and without a formal cartoon or exact design specification. The weaver will gather together the family resources or borrow the materials to create a rug. There are design conventions and traditions in these rugs but they are created by women in keeping with what her family and neighbors create. They are not bound to an exact design but copying is normal and innovation comes very slowly if at all. For instance the rugs from a village in Hamadan Province Iran will normally fall into two style types and all the rugs of each type will look very much the same. But if we look at them over a twenty year time frame we will see definite changes in style and color.  But it is very important to note that weaving technique stay fairly constant over long periods of time. Weaving technique will normally only change when there is some huge life changing event. Tekke Turkmenrugs stayed very consistent for hundreds of years but after they were conquered by the Czarist Russians the rugs became increasingly finer because Russian and Armenian traders paid more for finer rugs. The rugs stopped being an item of Tekke Turkmen culture and started being an item of commerce.  
More on Village Rugs Soon…


City Rugs





These rugs are commercial rugs made primarily for export. They tend to be larger, sturdier, more finely woven rugs. They are useually woven from a cartoon or other design. Because of thsi City Rugs usually have Resolved Corners while Tribal & Village Rugs rarely do. 
One key clue is resolved corners.

As we can see the border design flows around the corner which is a sign of a City Rug, The second rug has an abrupt cut off to the border design which is what we expect in Tribal & Village Rugs.


City Rugs can be fairly crude or very refined but as a group they are larger, tighter, heavier made then Village & Tribal Rugs. Still the line between the two gets blurred when for instance a great Qashqai Tribal Rug can be far more sophisticated than many city rugs. But while you are learning the broad groups don’t get lost in the fine points of distinction. 
Here are the big 6 Persian City Rugs
Tabriz Rugs (Turkish Knots)
Kashan Rugs (Persian Knots)
Sarouk Rugs (Persian Knots)
Kerman Rugs (Persian Knots)
Mashhad Rugs (Persian Knots)
Bijar Rugs (Persian Knots)

More on City Rugs  coming soon
Link to an interesting article:



Workshop Rugs
Mohammad Seirafian One of the Greatest Persian Master Workshop Ustads

I draw a line of distinction between City Rugs and Workshop Rugs. It is a fine line and the distinctions blur so compare it to automobiles. Even great city rugs can be compared to a standard Mercedes Benz, Corvette, or Cadillac. But for the most part they are mass production cars and no matter how nice one is your neighbor can go buy one just like it (if he has the money). Then there is the hand built limited production cars such as the Bugatti Veyron Pur Sang , Jaguar XKR 75, or the Lamborghini Reventón Roadster. Much higher standards, smaller numbers and closer supervision are some of the differences. Of course the price recognizes the exclusivity as well. 
Some of the Great Workshops include:
From Isfahan Workshops:



From Qum/Ghoum:

From Tabriz (area)
Hallmarks of the Workshop Rugs.
Far higher quality control. Even though many workshop rugs are made in the weavers home the Usatad or master inspects regularly and maintains strict quality control. Both city and workshop rugs use cartoons but the workshops hire the best artists and limit use of a design. Errors and material failures are common but in the best workshops these imperfections are not allowed.


More on Workshop Rugs coming soon

1 comment: